The Oscars have always been a topic of debate and controversy, with many fans and critics alike feeling that their favorite films and performances have been snubbed by the prestigious awards ceremony. From “Birdman” beating out “Boyhood” to Ava DuVernay not being recognized for her directing talents, the list of grievances is long and varied.
One theater reporter, Michael Paulson, still holds a grudge against the Oscars for choosing “Birdman” over “Boyhood,” citing the former as pretentious and obtuse compared to the moving and meaningful nature of the latter. Similarly, reporter Marc Tracy laments the lack of recognition for Greta Gerwig’s work on “Frances Ha,” a film he believes surpassed many others in its genre.
Other industry professionals, such as editor Maya Salam and deputy culture editor Barbara Chai, express their disappointment in the academy’s failure to acknowledge the talents of actors and directors like Michelle Pfeiffer, David Oyelowo, and Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor.
The list of snubs and disappointments goes on, with senior editor David Renard still bitter about “Shakespeare in Love” winning over “Saving Private Ryan,” and book critic Alexandra Jacobs feeling that Eddie Murphy was robbed of an Oscar for his performance in “Dreamgirls.”
Despite the controversies and disappointments, one thing is clear: the Oscars will always be a source of heated discussion and passionate opinions within the film industry. As critic at large A.O. Scott puts it, the credibility of the academy is often called into question with decisions like awarding “Dances With Wolves” the best picture. The debate rages on, and fans and critics alike will continue to voice their grievances and frustrations with the Oscars for years to come.
